Friday, December 30, 2011
Those “Guaranteed Income” Rental Home Investments
A recent inquiry from a Canadian journalist has me revisiting this topic, as there is now a burgeoning industry of selling “rental home investments” to foreign investors, particularly the Canadians and the Chinese. For instance, some unsuccessful builders of failed subdivisions in places like Arizona and Nevada are advertising their unsold homes as “rental home investments” for which they or their agents promise to rent and manage for foreign investors. Their ads often tout “guaranteed ROI of xx%” or “guaranteed rental income for two years”. Are such investments a good deal?
“Guaranteed rental income for the first two years” is a seller promise that should be interpreted as a sign of weakness, not security, because a rental property in a stable market need not be sold with any such guarantees. What often happens, too, is that the property’s previous asking price has been inflated to more than cover the amount of these guaranteed rents.
Enforceability of guarantees
Guarantees are not quite guarantees if the builder or manager goes out of business, even if just to emerge again as another legal entity (for example, if the principals of Get Rich Quick LLC dissolved their LLC and reorganized as Get Rich Guaranteed LLC). If the guaranteed rents stop coming in, there is also the logistical problem of filing a lawsuit far away from home to collect what is due, and foreign investors are at a disadvantage in negotiating the complex U.S. justice system. Accept this common piece of advice from Craigslist:
“Only a scammer will ‘guarantee’ your transaction.”
Recommended Due Diligence for U.S. rental homes
1. Try to get vacancy rate data for the community the home is in at the most granular level, whether it is the subdivision, the zip code, or the census tract. One helpful tool at the moment is the U.S. Census, which recently completed a decennial census with data as of April 1, 2010. The U.S. Census Bureau counted vacant housing units as of that date and will soon publish data down to the census tract level. For instance, realtors crow about Green Valley, Arizona, being the second fastest growing town in Arizona, itself one of the fastest growing states, all according to the U.S. Census, but may neglect to mention that in Green Valley, a suburb of Tucson, the Census counted 4581 vacant housing units out of a total of 17,322, equivalent to a vacancy rate of 26.5%. What will happen to a rental home there after the guaranteed rental income runs out after one or two years? Tucson isn’t much better, having a 15.9% rental vacancy rate.
2. Google the name of the seller and the management company and look for consumer and investor complaints. It helps to add the words “scam”, “fraud” or “complaint” to your search terms to get beyond the pretty web sites of the scammers. Try “MRI Overseas Property scam”, for instance. The really active fraudsters, though, will publish articles designed to show up in such search results, such as “Get Rich Quick LLC – No Scam!” or “Guaranteed Riches, LLC – No Complaints Here!”, and may even write their own highly favorable Wikipedia article, so keep on searching all the results. If the company is so new that nothing can be found in a background search, Google the name of the principal of the company, and that’s often where you will find a history of a swindler moving from state to state or even nation to nation to perpetrate scams.
After applying the aforementioned screening criteria, you should have a much smaller list of prospective investments.
Vernon Martin performs due diligence and appraisals on commercial and residential real estate throughout the world. He has 35 years of commercial appraisal experience and has worked in more than 20 countries, 43 U.S. states, and 5 Canadian provinces. He started his career at the global firm Jones Lang Wootton and went on to become the chief commercial appraiser at 3 national (U.S.) lending institutions, formerly taught Real Estate Valuation at California State University, Los Angeles and has authored many professional journal articles and two books. He has degrees from the University of Chicago and Southern Methodist University and is a Certified General Appraiser and a Certified Fraud Examiner. He also appraises specialty properties such as solar farms, wind farms, cannabis-related real estate, golf courses and ski resorts. If you have a particularly difficult property needing a valuation, send your inquiry to Mr. Martin and he may be able to help. For more information, call 1-323-788-1605, or e-mail him at firstname.lastname@example.org .